Shake Shack shares surged Wednesday after activist investor Jeff Smith disclosed that Starboard Value has taken a position worth several hundred million dollars in the burger chain — an announcement that landed the same morning the company beat Wall Street on earnings and traffic.
Smith, Starboard’s chief executive, revealed the new stake in an interview on Bloomberg Television. The stock climbed 11.4% in midday trading, reaching as high as $71.33.
Shake Shack reported second-quarter earnings of 43 cents a share against the 31 cents analysts expected, a beat of nearly 39%, though slightly below the 44 cents posted in the same quarter last year. The company topped estimates on both sales and earnings after drawing more diners into its restaurants.
Why an Activist Shows Up Here
Starboard’s arrival follows a punishing stretch for the stock. Shake Shack’s 90-day return had fallen 37% and its one-year total shareholder return was down nearly 54% before the recent bounce.
The low point came in May. Shares tumbled roughly 30% in a single afternoon after the chain reported an operating loss of $2.6 million and earnings that merely broke even against expectations of 12 cents a share, with revenue of $367 million missing the $372 million analysts modeled.
Chief Executive Rob Lynch attributed the shortfall to winter storms and to raised projections for store openings, and said higher beef costs remained a factor even as the rate of increase slowed. The Middle East conflict also weighed on results at the company’s several dozen licensed locations in the region, which Lynch said had experienced temporary closures, reduced hours and delivery-only operations at various points.
That combination — a strong brand, a beaten-down share price and a management team fighting cost and expansion problems — is exactly the profile activist funds hunt for.
Activist investors typically press management teams on operational efficiency, operating margins, store expansion strategy and shareholder returns. When a fund with Starboard’s profile builds a position of this size, investors read it as a signal that the target has earnings power it is not currently capturing.
The Value Case
Shake Shack’s problem has never been demand. It has been unit economics — the cost of building and running restaurants that carry premium pricing in expensive urban real estate, against a fast-casual field where competitors operate at lower cost per location.
Two levers are available. The company can slow the pace of new openings to protect margins, or it can attack the cost structure of the existing base. Activists generally favor the first.
The quarterly beat gives Starboard a stronger hand. A fund arguing that a company underperforms its potential is in better position when that company has just demonstrated it can grow traffic. Shake Shack had broadened its full-year EBITDA outlook to a range of $230 million to $245 million while reiterating revenue guidance of $1.6 billion to $1.7 billion.
Insiders Were Already Buying
Company leadership had been adding to positions well before Wednesday. Director Daniel Meyer, who founded the chain, purchased 32,258 shares in mid-May at an average of $61.88 apiece, a roughly $2 million transaction that lifted his direct holding to 378,670 shares. Insiders bought a combined 50,616 shares worth about $3.1 million over the trailing ninety days, and hold 8.32% of the company.
Institutional money had also been accumulating during the decline. Swedbank opened a position worth roughly $84 million in the fourth quarter, while Jefferies, Madison Asset Management, Intech and D.A. Davidson all initiated or expanded holdings over the same stretch.
Analysts carry a consensus price target near $83 on the stock. The company’s next report is expected October 29.
What happens between now and then depends on whether Starboard stays quiet. Funds that disclose a position on television are rarely planning to hold silently.
JBizNews Desk | New York
© JBizNews.com All Rights Reserved. Reproduction or distribution without written permission is prohibited.