Maran Rav Moshe Hillel Hirsch, rosh yeshiva of Slabodka, is reportedly prepared to consider a proposal from Gadi Eisenkot’s political bloc that would resolve the status of yeshiva bochurim facing military conscription, despite reservations within the chareidi community about cooperating with parties traditionally opposed to yeshiva draft exemptions.
The significant development was disclosed Wednesday evening by political commentator Avi Ravina during an interview with Avi Mimran on Kol Chai Radio, where he stressed that no concrete proposal has yet been presented to the rosh yeshiva.
According to Ravina, Rav Hirsch has not ruled out an arrangement with Eisenkot, Avigdor Lieberman or other opposition leaders, provided they present a serious and workable solution to the draft crisis.
“I learned just within the past hour, specifically from the more militant chareidi side that did not favor the contacts with the left-wing parties, that Rosh Yeshiva Rav Moshe Hillel Hirsch still has not taken this possibility off the table,” Ravina reported.
He described the message he had received regarding Rav Hirsch’s position as straightforward.
“There is no proposal, no proposal. Nobody has brought me a proposal. They talk about Eisenkot, they talk about Lieberman. Bring a proposal, and we will discuss it,” Ravina quoted the message as saying.
Ravina explained that the position leaves open the possibility of cooperation with parties that chareidi leaders have historically been reluctant to join, provided a genuine agreement can be reached concerning the military service obligations of yeshiva students.
“If there is a real proposal that can resolve the draft issue, even the left-wing bloc would be acceptable,” he said, while cautioning that “at the moment, we are very far away.”
The remarks represent Ravina’s account of the rosh yeshiva’s position and were not issued as an official statement by Rav Hirsch.
The report comes amid intensive negotiations over the formation of Israel’s next government, with the question of military conscription emerging as a potentially decisive factor in determining whether the chareidi parties will cooperate with Eisenkot’s bloc.
The reported willingness to examine a new proposal comes despite indications that previous draft arrangements have failed to satisfy the chareidi leadership. Channel 12 reported that Rav Hirsch had rejected a plan presented by the opposition bloc, while other reports indicated that the sides remained far apart over the scope of exemptions and the legal protections that would be provided to yeshiva students.
Earlier reports indicated that Rav Hirsch had placed particular emphasis on resolving the legal status of yeshiva bochurim, including those currently classified as draft evaders, rather than making the restoration of government funding the immediate priority.
Meanwhile, the political negotiations have been further complicated by Wednesday’s unusual meeting between Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu and Naftali Bennett, chairman of the B’Yachad party.
The meeting, held at the Knesset, lasted approximately two and a half hours. Bennett’s associates described it as a security briefing, but political commentators questioned whether the discussion also involved negotiations over a possible national unity government.
Political analyst Shalom Yerushalmi, who participated in the Kol Chai discussion, argued that both Netanyahu and Bennett had political reasons to explore such an arrangement.
“Netanyahu has a clear interest in advancing the entire issue of a unity government, because this is the only option he has to establish a unity government in order to remain prime minister, to somehow remain in power,” Yerushalmi said.
He suggested that Netanyahu could seek to use Bennett as an intermediary to persuade other opposition leaders to consider joining a unity government.
Bennett, meanwhile, may have reservations about participating in a minority government dependent on Arab parties, Yerushalmi suggested, noting that Bennett’s party secured only seven Knesset seats in the recent election.
Ravina agreed that the meeting likely included political discussions, although he acknowledged that security matters were also addressed.
According to his account, the meeting initially took place in a political setting, with the national security adviser and Netanyahu’s military secretary joining later.
“Why does Bennett need to go into Netanyahu for a security briefing if he is not the leader of the other bloc? Clearly, political matters were discussed there,” Ravina said.
Ravina also raised the possibility that Bennett was positioning himself for another election by demonstrating that he had explored every available route to forming a government, including negotiations with Netanyahu.
“Bennett is simply making certain moves in order to reach another election,” Ravina suggested.
That assessment was presented as Ravina’s political interpretation, rather than a declared intention by Bennett.
Another possibility under discussion within the opposition involves establishing a minority government with 48 Knesset members, supported externally by Arab parties.
Yerushalmi said Eisenkot, Yair Lapid and Yair Golan were prepared to consider such an arrangement as an immediate means of replacing Netanyahu, with the possibility of expanding the coalition afterward.
“There is the axis of Eisenkot, Lapid and Yair Golan, who are ready at this moment to establish a minority government, a government of 48, supported by the Arab parties,” Yerushalmi said.
Ravina reported that Eisenkot had urged opposition leaders to accelerate the establishment of a government, even if the initial coalition would be narrow and temporary.
Bennett, however, continues to explore the possibility of a unity agreement with Likud, while Lieberman has been examining whether understandings can be reached with the chareidi parties.
The discussion also addressed the opposition bloc’s growing control over parliamentary proceedings following the election of Matan Kahana as Knesset speaker.
Yerushalmi said the new parliamentary majority was already using its position to advance legislation and secure control of important Knesset committees.
“What is happening now in the Knesset is the establishment of parliamentary facts on the ground,” he said.
Ravina pointed to preliminary votes on legislation intended to reverse elements of the judicial overhaul advanced by Netanyahu’s government, including changes affecting the composition and operation of the Judicial Selection Committee.
He noted that the original legislation had been the subject of lengthy parliamentary deliberations and extensive public demonstrations, while the new majority had already begun advancing measures to reverse it.
“People went out into the streets for years, and there were hours upon hours of discussions,” Ravina said.
The repeal proposals have so far advanced only through preliminary readings and have not become law.
The commentators also discussed confrontations in the Knesset plenum involving Deputy Speaker Ahmad Tibi, who ordered several right-wing lawmakers removed following disputes over accusations of supporting terrorism.
Ravina suggested that the confrontations attracted considerable attention but that the more consequential developments were taking place through parliamentary votes and legislative proceedings.
For the chareidi parties, however, the immediate question remains whether any prospective coalition can offer an acceptable and enforceable solution to the draft crisis.
According to Ravina’s account, Rav Hirsch has not closed the door to considering an agreement with Eisenkot’s bloc, but any such arrangement would first have to be presented in concrete terms and address the status of yeshiva bochurim.
For now, no agreement has been reached, and the reported willingness to examine a proposal should not be confused with approval of the draft plans already discussed.
{Matzav.com}