Logo

Jooish

HomeSitesGroupsStatusPodcasts
Sign InSign Up
HomeSitesGroupsStatusPodcastsSign In
Matzav

Shas MK Moshe Abutbul Pushes Back at Chareidi Critics: ‘Things Were Accomplished’

Aug 17, 2026·4 min read

Shas MK Moshe Abutbul is pushing back against growing criticism within the Chareidi community over the draft crisis, arguing that Chareidi lawmakers did take significant action over the past four years but repeatedly encountered obstacles from Israel’s judicial system.

Speaking in an interview as Israel moves closer to elections, Abutbul acknowledged that Shas and United Torah Judaism face difficult questions from Chareidi voters over what they accomplished to protect the status of bnei yeshivos.

Abutbul said he recently participated in panels with bnei Torah and baalei batim, where he encountered people demanding answers about the actions of their elected representatives.

“There are very pointed questions there,” Abutbul said, adding that once the sequence of events is explained, the picture becomes considerably more complicated. “The public is very, very thirsty for answers.”

According to Abutbul, much of what Chareidi representatives actually did over the past several years was never adequately communicated to the public.

One of the central questions facing Shas and UTJ as elections approach is what they accomplished during the past four years toward resolving the status of bnei yeshivos. Abutbul argued that the war dramatically altered the political and public environment in which the issue was being addressed.

“During a war, it is not exactly the time when you can talk about an exemption from military service or anything else, when an Israeli mother is sending several sons to the battlefield,” he said.

Abutbul said the government’s effort to overhaul the judicial system was also intended, in part, to create a legal framework that could withstand a future High Court challenge to legislation governing the status of bnei yeshivos.

He maintained that the fundamental obstacle is not necessarily a lack of political votes in the Knesset, but the judiciary’s ability to overturn or obstruct legislation passed by elected lawmakers.

As an example, Abutbul pointed to legislation concerning arrests that was advanced by Shas chairman Aryeh Deri. He said that despite securing sufficient political support for the measure, it ultimately encountered a legal barrier.

“This is not only a political problem; it is a fundamental legal problem that must be addressed at its root,” Abutbul said.

Without fundamental change, he argued, legislative achievements can ultimately prove meaningless.

“It is like a person who comes and fills a bag with something, but at the bottom you have a very large hole,” he said.

Abutbul therefore identified the judicial system as one of the central issues Chareidi parties must address in the coming election and the next government.

“We must change and reshape the face of the High Court, so that it will be a body that does not interfere in things that are legislated,” he said.

Asked why changes that were not completed during the outgoing government should be expected to succeed during the next term, Abutbul said the war made far-reaching reforms considerably more difficult and argued that voters now understand what is at stake.

“Everyone knows that 90 percent of this issue is fundamentally addressing the judicial system,” he said.

Abutbul added that steps have already been taken in areas involving the powers of legal advisers, the Police Internal Investigations Department and other components of the legal system.

During the second part of the interview, Abutbul turned from politics to the olam haTorah, describing a major Torah project he has initiated involving the study of Shas.

The project is intended to compile, alongside each masechta, relevant sugyos appearing elsewhere throughout the Talmud, allowing a person learning a particular subject to easily access related discussions found in other masechtos.

According to Abutbul, approximately 200 avreichim have worked on the undertaking and have already identified nearly 8,000 references and connections between different sugyos throughout Shas.

The plan calls for approximately 100 to 150 supplementary pages to accompany each masechta. The existing text of the Gemara will remain unchanged, while the additional material will present parallel and related sugyos from elsewhere in Shas.

Abutbul said the Otzar HaChochma project has assisted in making the material available to the public, enabling lomdim to review the work, submit comments and suggest additions as the project moves toward completion.

He added that the initiative has received endorsements from leading gedolei Torah, including the Moetzet Chachmei HaTorah.

Abutbul concluded by saying that despite the political and legal battles facing the Chareidi community, he believes its most fundamental response remains strengthening Torah learning.

“Our remedy against all these blows, truly, truly, is, with Hashem’s help, to learn Torah, to add Torah, to add batei medrash, to add batei knesses.”

{Matzav.com}

View original on Matzav