
COURT DEFEAT FOR MAMDANI: Federal Judge Orders NYC to Hand Over Shelter Records to ICE Despite Sanctuary City Objections
A federal judge has ordered New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s administration to comply with an Immigration and Customs Enforcement subpoena seeking information about homeless shelter residents who may be in the United States illegally and have criminal histories, rejecting the city’s objections that the request violates its sanctuary policies.
In a 12-page ruling issued Friday, U.S. District Judge Lewis Kaplan directed the city to cooperate with federal immigration authorities seeking identifying information, including names and dates of birth, of certain men residing at a Bronx homeless shelter.
The decision represents a significant legal setback for the Mamdani administration, which has opposed the Trump administration’s immigration enforcement efforts and argued that federal authorities were improperly attempting to use subpoena powers to obtain information protected by New York City’s sanctuary laws.
Federal officials told the court that they are investigating whether individuals staying at the shelter are unlawfully present in the country and subject to removal. ICE agreed to narrow its request to residents accused of specified violent offenses rather than seek information about the shelter’s entire population.
As part of that arrangement, federal authorities consented to having a court-appointed special master review the relevant records and determine which individuals fall within the subpoena’s permitted scope.
“In light of the agency’s consent to the use of a special master, and deferring to the agency’s assessment that the records are relevant to its legitimate investigation, the Court thus concludes the subpoena concerns a matter which is material and relevant to the enforcement of the federal immigration laws,” Kaplan wrote.
The judge instructed the city and federal government to develop a plan for implementing the ruling within two weeks.
City Hall has not announced whether it intends to challenge the decision. Mamdani spokesperson Ivonne Rodriguez said the administration is “evaluating next steps” when asked about a possible appeal.
New York Attorney General Letitia James also indicated that her office was examining the ruling and considering whether to pursue further legal action.
“I’m familiar with the ruling and we’re reviewing the possibility of an appeal,” James said while attending the annual Somos conference in Puerto Rico.
The legal dispute began in August 2025, when ICE initially demanded identifying information for male residents at two city-operated shelters. New York officials refused, arguing that the request was excessively broad and lacked a legitimate investigative basis.
Federal authorities subsequently revised the subpoena several times, eventually concentrating on the Bruckner shelter at 825 East 141st Street in the Bronx. The facility, located in the Mott Haven neighborhood, was established to accommodate approximately 2,200 men and generated opposition from neighborhood residents and local elected officials when it opened.
During the court proceedings, the city maintained that ICE was conducting a “fishing expedition” and attempting to “leverage the federal administrative subpoena power to circumvent and undermine the City’s sanctuary city laws.” City attorneys also characterized the federal demand as “more political than investigatory.”
Kaplan rejected those arguments, finding that ICE had demonstrated a legitimate immigration enforcement purpose and that the city had failed to establish that producing the requested information would impose an unreasonable burden.
The ruling does not authorize ICE to obtain the names of every shelter resident. Instead, an independent special master will screen the records and restrict the information released to individuals with serious criminal histories.
Immigrant advocacy organizations have urged Mamdani to appeal, warning that compliance could establish a precedent for federal immigration authorities to obtain sensitive information from municipal agencies.
Murad Awawdeh, president of the New York Immigration Coalition and a political ally of Mamdani, condemned the federal government’s original demands.
“ICE’s opening demand was the name and date of birth of every man sleeping in city shelters. That is a dragnet, not an investigation,” he said. “The City must appeal, and City Hall and Albany must limit what shelters collect and keep about the people they serve. ICE cannot subpoena a record that does not exist.”
Mamdani has repeatedly criticized ICE operations in New York City and pledged to defend the city’s sanctuary policies, which restrict cooperation between municipal agencies and federal immigration enforcement.
Speaking at a rally in Puerto Rico earlier in the week, the mayor accused immigration authorities of conducting what he called a campaign of intimidation and violence, arguing that the midterm election results demonstrated growing public opposition to federal enforcement tactics.
“We have seen firsthand in New York City the devastation that ICE causes — bullets fired in our streets, family members disappeared, parents abducted, the life of a 5-year-old child placed into danger,” Mamdani said. “Our country must move forward from a chapter of terror and start with a chapter of humanity.”
His comments followed a controversial immigration enforcement operation in New York during which federal agents fired shots on a busy street at a minivan containing a young child.
The Mamdani administration has not announced whether it will appeal Kaplan’s decision. Under Friday’s order, the city and federal government have 14 days to submit their proposal for appointing and compensating the special master who will oversee the release of records.