
DRAFT LAW COMPROMISE: Lieberman Signals Flexibility With Chareidi Parties, Says 2018 Proposal Could Form Basis for Agreement
Yisrael Beiteinu chairman Avigdor Lieberman is signaling a willingness to reach an agreement with the chareidi parties over military conscription, saying his 2018 draft legislation could provide a starting point for negotiations aimed at forming a new government and preventing another election.
In a statement issued Sunday, Lieberman defended his recent contacts with chareidi political leaders, insisting that his readiness to negotiate does not mean he has retreated from his longstanding demands regarding military service. He also firmly rejected any coalition that would rely on the support of Ra’am or the Joint List.
“A willingness to compromise does not mean abandoning values and principles,” Liberman began.
The Yisrael Beiteinu leader sharply criticized political commentators and others who have questioned his motives since reports emerged of discussions with the chareidi factions.
“In recent days, I have been watching a parade of foolishness from a series of commentators, partisan journalists, bots, and people with preconceived notions, sometimes with a distinctly racist undertone. No matter what I say, what I do, or what the truth is, they are always busy attributing malicious motives and inventing conspiracies.”
Lieberman accused some of his critics of applying a double standard, arguing that they oppose his efforts to negotiate with the chareidi parties while favoring a coalition dependent on Arab factions.
“Those attacking me for trying to reach understandings with the haredi parties are among the same people who would prefer to establish a government dependent on Ra’am and the Joint List – parties some of whose Knesset members openly identify with Hamas, describe it as a charitable organization, and accuse the State of Israel of genocide and crimes against humanity,” he said.
He declared that he would not participate in such an arrangement, warning that it would endanger Israel’s security and ultimately strengthen Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu politically.
“I want to make this absolutely clear: It will not happen. I will not lend a hand to the establishment of such a government, which, in my view, would harm security and bring Netanyahu back to power.
“In the reality that has emerged, in order to prevent another election and bring an end to the Netanyahu era, there is no avoiding difficult decisions and making choices on issues where flexibility can be shown and understandings can be reached.”
The comments come amid complicated coalition negotiations following Israel’s October 27 elections, which left neither major political camp with enough seats to establish a government independently. The possibility of cooperation between Lieberman and the chareidi parties has attracted particular attention because of his years of opposition to exemptions from military service for yeshiva students.
Lieberman maintained that negotiations should not be confused with surrendering the positions on which his party campaigned.
“Reaching an understanding does not mean abandoning principles, and dialogue does not mean erasing red lines.”
On the central issue of military service, Lieberman reiterated his preference for a universal conscription requirement while acknowledging that the election results necessitate examining compromises.
” I still believe that the correct model is a conscription law that applies to everyone. At the same time, in light of the election results, we must examine possibilities for reaching agreements, including on the basis of frameworks developed in the past.”
He specifically pointed to the conscription legislation he introduced while serving as defense minister in 2018, suggesting that the earlier proposal could be revised to address Israel’s current military requirements.
“In 2018, I introduced a conscription bill drafted by the IDF and the defense establishment. Subsequently, the Shkedi Report was published, and the current coalition formulated its own bill.
“It is clear to me that following the events of October 7, even the law I proposed in 2018 requires changes and adjustments, but it still constitutes a suitable basis for reaching agreements.”
The 2018 proposal included enlistment targets for chareidi men and financial penalties for yeshivos if recruitment goals were not met. It also provided for exemptions under certain conditions. Its provisions differ from more recent proposals, including legislation advanced by Likud MK Boaz Bismuth, which introduced additional restrictions and sanctions. The competing frameworks have become a focus of renewed political debate as coalition negotiators search for a formula acceptable to the chareidi parties.
Lieberman emphasized that his willingness to reconsider earlier legislation does not diminish his commitment to expanding military service or improving conditions for soldiers.
“I have not abandoned the principle of conscription, nor my commitment to expanding benefits and improving the status of reservists and career military personnel.
“I would remind everyone that during my tenure as Finance Minister, I increased the salaries of soldiers performing mandatory service by 50%, and subsequently incorporated the ‘From Uniform to Studies’ program into the state budget.”
The Yisrael Beiteinu chairman also responded to speculation that his maneuvering was intended to position him for the premiership or interfere with Gadi Eisenkot’s efforts to establish a coalition.
“I am not acting out of personal ambition to become prime minister at any cost,” he wrote.
“I have always emphasized that, as far as I am concerned, it is an option, not an obsession. Since 2019, I have received countless tempting offers from the other side. I am not preoccupied with political maneuvering, nor am I trying to undermine anyone.”
Lieberman’s latest statement follows his announcement Friday that he was prepared to reconsider his longstanding refusal to sit in a government with the chareidi parties. He has maintained three central conditions for the next government: Netanyahu must leave office, Israel must avoid another election, and the coalition must not depend on Ra’am or the Joint List.
He ended his statement by insisting that his decisions would be guided by what he considers Israel’s national interests rather than personal political calculations.
“I act, and will continue to act, out of one commitment alone: the good of the State of Israel and the Jewish people. That is what has guided me throughout, and that alone will be at the forefront of my mind in every decision I make.”