
DRAFT LAW SHOWDOWN: UTJ Demands Concrete Guarantees as Eisenkot and Lieberman Agree to Continue Chareidi Coalition Talks
United Torah Judaism is demanding binding political guarantees that legislation protecting yeshiva bochurim from military conscription will actually be enacted before it agrees to support a government led by Gadi Eisenkot, with discussions reportedly including a proposal to appoint MK Yaakov Asher as temporary Knesset speaker to ensure that the legislation advances without delay.
According to a report Monday evening by Ynet, the possibility of installing Asher as interim speaker was raised during negotiations between UTJ representatives and members of the emerging anti-Netanyahu coalition. The proposal was discussed before Monday’s agreement between Yisrael Beiteinu chairman Avigdor Lieberman and Eisenkot, leader of the Yashar party, concerning the next Knesset speaker.
Under the arrangement being considered by UTJ, Asher would temporarily control the Knesset’s parliamentary agenda, allowing him to bring the proposed draft legislation to a vote immediately. The position would serve as a political safeguard against a repeat of previous coalition agreements that promised action on the draft issue but ultimately produced no legislation.
The proposal, however, predates the understanding reached Monday between Lieberman and Eisenkot that the next Knesset speaker would come from Eisenkot’s Yashar party. It remains unclear whether the possibility of appointing Asher temporarily is still being considered.
UTJ officials have reportedly made clear that they are no longer prepared to rely exclusively on written coalition agreements or verbal commitments from prospective coalition partners.
Their position reflects deep frustration with the outgoing Netanyahu government, which entered office with explicit commitments to resolve the military draft issue but failed to pass the promised legislation throughout its term.
Despite repeated assurances from Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu and his coalition partners, efforts to establish a legal framework protecting full-time yeshiva students became mired in political disputes and were never completed.
UTJ negotiators are therefore insisting on practical parliamentary mechanisms that would guarantee the legislation is brought forward and enacted, rather than simply including another commitment in a coalition agreement.
In a separate development Monday, Lieberman and Eisenkot reached an understanding on the leadership of the next Knesset, agreeing that the speaker would be selected from Eisenkot’s Yashar party.
Following their meeting, Yashar announced that the two leaders “expressed their full confidence in their ability to form a stable government for four years.”
The agreement represents a concession by Lieberman, who had previously supported appointing Yair Lapid to the speakership. Although the position is now expected to go to Yashar, the party has not publicly identified its intended candidate.
One possibility under discussion is appointing a party leader who would relinquish the speakership upon the establishment of a new government, avoiding a situation in which the parliamentary leader belongs to a different political camp than the governing coalition.
Eisenkot received the mandate to form Israel’s next government from President Yitzchak Herzog after securing recommendations from 67 Knesset members, including representatives of the Arab parties.
Under Israeli law, Eisenkot has 28 days to assemble a coalition, giving him until December 6. Herzog may grant an additional extension of up to 14 days if further negotiations are necessary.
Lieberman had previously demanded that the Knesset vote to remove current Speaker Amir Ohana during the opening session of the new parliament. Following his discussions with Eisenkot, however, he appears willing to allow additional time in exchange for the agreement that the position will go to Yashar.
UTJ, meanwhile, has rejected a request to participate in an immediate effort to replace Ohana before a new government is established.
In a letter to Yashar faction chairman Roy Folkman, Asher explained that his party believes the speakership should change hands only when a new coalition is sworn in, rather than during the Knesset’s inaugural session.
“This is proper, and this is what was customary in the past, other than a single exception. This is to prevent the creation of an absurd situation in which the Knesset speaker could be at odds with the incoming government,” Asher wrote.
The decision does not rule out future cooperation with Eisenkot, but it indicates that UTJ is unwilling to surrender its parliamentary leverage before obtaining meaningful commitments on the draft issue.
A senior UTJ official described the coming days as particularly important for determining whether the emerging coalition is prepared to reach an acceptable arrangement.
“We have a significant week ahead of us regarding cooperation with the change bloc,” the official said.
UTJ representatives have emphasized that any agreement must preserve the existing arrangements governing yeshiva students and provide concrete assurances that the next government will protect their ability to continue learning without facing military conscription.