Logo

Jooish

HomeSitesGroupsStatusPodcasts
Sign InSign Up
Matzav

COURT OVERRULES STATE: Israeli Supreme Court Orders Recognition of Private Orthodox Conversions for Immigration

Nov 12, 2026·4 min read

Israel’s Supreme Court ruled unanimously Thursday that the government must recognize conversions performed by a private Orthodox bais din headed by former Shas MK Rabbi Chaim Amsalem for purposes of immigration under the Law of Return, rejecting an appeal filed by the Population and Immigration Authority.

The decision represents another significant judicial intervention in Israel’s conversion system, allowing individuals who underwent conversion through the private Ahavat Hager bais din to qualify for immigration status without having their conversions recognized by the state’s official conversion establishment.

The ruling was issued by a three-justice panel consisting of Supreme Court President Yitzchak Amit and Justices Yael Willner and Khaled Kabub.

The case originated with Rosanie Michal Reyes, a citizen of the Philippines who had been employed in Israel as a caregiver and underwent conversion through Ahavat Hager in 2018. Her application for recognition under the Law of Return became the subject of a legal dispute after state authorities challenged the standing of the private conversion court.

In rejecting the government’s position, the justices determined that Ahavat Hager qualifies as a serious Orthodox conversion institution that carefully evaluates candidates and examines the sincerity of their commitment throughout the conversion process.

The court also found no sufficient legal basis for treating Ahavat Hager differently from the Giyur K’Halacha network, a private conversion framework established by the ITIM organization whose conversions have already been recognized for Law of Return purposes.

Rabbi Amsalem, who heads Ahavat Hager, also serves as a senior dayan within the Giyur K’Halacha network, a connection the justices considered relevant when examining the two institutions.

The ruling concerns eligibility for immigration under the Law of Return and does not, by itself, establish that conversions performed by Ahavat Hager must be accepted by the Chief Rabbinate for matters such as marriage and divorce.

In his written opinion, Justice Amit addressed the Torah’s approach to accepting geirim, emphasizing the obligation to treat those seeking to join Klal Yisroel with seriousness while avoiding unnecessary barriers.

Citing the Gemara and the Rambam, Amit referred to the traditional instructions given to a prospective ger, including the requirement to inform the candidate about the difficulties and suffering historically experienced by the Jewish people.

“What prompted you to come and convert? Do you not know that the Jewish people at this time are afflicted, oppressed, persecuted, and beset by suffering? If he says, ‘I know, and I am unworthy,’ he is accepted immediately.”

Justices Willner and Kabub joined Amit’s decision, making the ruling unanimous.

The ruling was welcomed by Rabbi Dr. Seth Farber, founder and chairman of ITIM and the Giyur K’Halacha conversion network, who accused Israeli authorities of creating unnecessary obstacles for individuals seeking Orthodox conversion.

“Conversion is not a wall that needs to be fortified, but a gateway that must be opened with seriousness, adherence to Jewish law, and love,” Farber said.

Farber criticized the fact that Israel’s highest civil court had invoked the Rambam to emphasize the importance of accepting sincere conversion candidates, arguing that the government’s policies had failed to reflect that principle.

“When the Supreme Court has to quote Maimonides to remind the Jewish state that ‘he is accepted immediately,’ it is a disgrace for the state,” he said.

He also pointed to the continuing absence of comprehensive conversion legislation, despite years of legal disputes concerning the recognition of private botei din.

“Ten years after the Regachova ruling, there is still no conversion law, the state conversion authority has been headed by an acting director for more than three years, and the state continues to waste resources fighting against first-rate Orthodox rabbinical courts,” Farber charged.

The decision follows earlier Supreme Court rulings recognizing conversions performed outside the state rabbinate for immigration purposes, including a 2022 decision involving private Orthodox conversion courts. The legal distinction between civil recognition under the Law of Return and religious recognition by the Chief Rabbinate remains central to the controversy.

Farber said his organization would continue providing conversion services independently of the state system.

“As long as the state fails to do its job, ITIM and Giyur K’Halacha will fill the vacuum. It is time for the government to stop fighting converts and start fulfilling the Torah’s commandment: ‘You shall love the stranger.'”

View original on Matzav
HomeSitesGroupsStatusPodcastsSign In