
DRAFT LAW DEMANDS: Chassidic Leaders Insist on Written Pledges From All 48 Opposition MKs and Override Clause
Israel’s chassidic leadership is reportedly preparing a series of far-reaching conditions for any agreement with the opposition’s so-called change bloc on legislation protecting yeshiva bochurim from military conscription. Among the demands are personal written commitments from all 48 members of the bloc to support a draft exemption law, along with a provision allowing the Knesset to override a Supreme Court ruling striking down the legislation.
According to a report Thursday by Amit Segal of Channel 12 News, the demands were discussed Tuesday at a meeting held in the home of a son of the Slonimer Rebbe. Participants reportedly included a prominent Rebbe, representatives of the Gerer and Vizhnitzer chassidic communities, and additional rabbonim who gathered to formulate the conditions that would govern negotiations with the opposition.
The most significant demand would require every one of the 48 lawmakers belonging to the change bloc to personally sign a written undertaking supporting legislation exempting yeshiva students from military service. The requirement would apply even to politicians who have publicly and strongly opposed such exemptions, including Yontan Shalev and Matan Kahana.
The insistence on individual signatures appears intended to prevent a situation in which opposition leaders reach an understanding with the chareidi parties but subsequently fail to secure the votes of their own lawmakers. Under the proposed arrangement, general assurances from party leaders would not be sufficient; each participating MK would have to personally commit to supporting the legislation.
A second major condition involves the inclusion of an override clause that would permit the Knesset to reenact or preserve the draft exemption law even if the Supreme Court rules that it is unconstitutional.
Such a demand would create a substantial political difficulty for opposition parties that spent years campaigning against judicial reform proposals and efforts to restrict the authority of the Supreme Court. Accepting an override provision for the draft law would require those parties to support a legal mechanism they have previously opposed.
The chassidic representatives reportedly pointed to a precedent established during the government of Prime Minister Yitzchak Rabin, when an override mechanism was enacted in connection with legislation restricting the importation of non-kosher meat into Israel. That arrangement is being cited as a possible model for protecting a future draft law from judicial intervention.
Another noteworthy element emerged from a document prepared ahead of the meeting, which appeared to suggest that coordination with Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara might be possible regarding the proposed legislation.
The document stated: “As noted, coordination with the attorney general is possible, and therefore this is the smallest difficulty from our perspective. However, as is her habit, she leaves unclear which principles the coordination covers and which reservations still remain.”
The reference raises questions about whether preliminary discussions have already taken place with the attorney general’s office, although the report did not establish that any formal agreement had been reached or that the attorney general had approved a particular legislative framework.
The demands come amid growing efforts by opposition leaders to assemble a coalition capable of replacing Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu. The change bloc currently controls 48 Knesset seats, while United Torah Judaism holds seven and Shas six. Bringing both chareidi parties into the coalition would produce a narrow 61-seat majority.
Yisrael Beytenu chairman Avigdor Lieberman recently removed his longstanding opposition to negotiating with the chareidi parties, opening the possibility of a coalition that would have been considered highly unlikely before the elections. However, substantial disagreements remain over the draft law, religious issues, and the composition of a future government.
Earlier this week, reports indicated that chareidi negotiators were seeking a temporary arrangement lasting between one year and 18 months, during which arrests, sanctions, and enforcement measures against yeshiva students would be suspended while a permanent draft law was formulated. The chareidi representatives also reportedly sought advance legal assurances that such an arrangement could withstand judicial challenges.
The latest demands appear to go considerably further, requiring not only political commitments but also explicit legislative protection against Supreme Court intervention.
Separately, reports have indicated that the Slonimer Rebbe remains deeply opposed to the prospect of a government headed by the left, presenting another major obstacle to efforts to secure chassidic support for a change-bloc coalition. His position carries particular significance within Agudas Yisroel, where the views of the chassidic Rebbes play a central role in determining the party’s political direction.
{Matzav.com}