
Historic: Psak Din Preserves Stuchiner Kehillah’s Continuity, Defines Ropshitz-Stuchin Identity
A historic psak din signed Wednesday evening has brought clarity to the Stuchiner legacy in Boro Park, preserving the distinct identity of the established kehillah under the previous Rebbe’s grandson while defining a separate path for Ropshitz-Stuchin.
The ruling was issued by a beis din consisting of Rav Shimon Yitzchok Schlesinger, Rav Yekusiel Zalman Gross, and Rav Chaim Aharon Monderer, following a din Torah concerning the names, titles and activities of the two kehillos.
At the center of the decision is the distinction between the original Stuchiner kehillah and the independent kehillah led by Harav Mordche Menashe Zilber, shlita. Harav Eliezer Yehoshua Yudkowsky, shlita, continues his grandfather’s established kehillah and retains the exclusive title of Stuchiner Rebbe. Rav Zilber, whose kehillah was previously known as Toldos Yehudah d’Chasidei Stuchin, may use the title Ropshitz-Stuchiner Rebbe, which he has already adopted.
The psak din also sets guidelines for the names used by the mosdos and on publications. The separate kehillah must use Ropshitz-Stuchin together, with Ropshitz first and both names in the same size, rather than Stuchin alone.
The beis din further ruled that the Ropshitz-Stuchin kehillah may not identify itself as Toldos Yehudah or by a similar name. Publication of the previous Rebbe’s “Minchas Yehuda” requires the permission of Rav Yudkowsky, identified in the ruling as his halachic heir. Other Torah writings associated with the dynasty may be published in accordance with the ruling’s naming conditions.
The relatively short period in which the din Torah was completed provides a clear framework for both communities, with the identity of the original kehillah maintained and that of Ropshitz-Stuchin separately defined.
The Stuchiner Rebbe had previously addressed the importance of approaching such proceedings with the proper intentions during a Shabbos gathering at his beis medrash.
According to a Hebrew-language account by Dovid Damen, the Rebbe emphasized that the purpose of appearing before a beis din is to understand what the Torah requires, rather than to focus on winning or defeating another party.
The account describes the Rebbe becoming emotional as he spoke about acting for kiddush Sheim Shamayim and making sure that no one is hurt in the process.
With the ruling finalized, the Stuchiner kehillah continues the mesorah of the previous Rebbe under his grandson, while Ropshitz-Stuchin may develop its independent kehillah within the guidelines established by the beis din. The dayanim’s call for peace and mutual respect sets the tone for that next chapter.