
DRAFT DEAL IN THE WORKS: Eisenkot Bloc Offers Chareidim One-Year Freeze on Arrests to Secure New Government
A new proposal being considered by Gadi Eisenkot’s political bloc would suspend military draft enforcement and arrests of yeshiva bochurim for up to one year in exchange for United Torah Judaism’s cooperation in establishing a new government, according to a report Thursday evening.
The emerging arrangement, reported by Amir Ettinger of Ynet, is intended to overcome one of the biggest obstacles facing Eisenkot’s efforts to assemble a coalition following the recent elections: the demand by chareidi parties for binding guarantees protecting yeshiva bochurim from military conscription.
Under the proposal, the incoming government would immediately introduce a one-year suspension of enforcement measures against chareidim who have not reported for military service. During that period, coalition partners would negotiate legislation establishing a permanent framework for the status of yeshiva students.
The proposed legislation would reportedly be based on a revised version of the military draft bill advanced by Yisroel Beiteinu chairman Avigdor Lieberman in 2018, with modifications intended to make it acceptable to both chareidi leadership and Israel’s Supreme Court.
The discussions have gained momentum following Lieberman’s decision to remove his previous opposition to negotiating with United Torah Judaism, opening the possibility of cooperation between two parties that have long been sharply divided over the draft issue.
Earlier this week, UTJ chairman MK Yaakov Asher held a significant meeting with Lieberman, their first substantive discussion aimed at exploring whether a mutually acceptable draft arrangement could be reached.
The meeting focused on developing legislation that could receive the approval of Rav Dov Landau while also surviving judicial review by the Supreme Court.
Asher has made clear that UTJ’s participation in any coalition negotiations depends on three fundamental conditions: legislation regulating the status of yeshiva bochurim, continued government funding for chareidi educational institutions without requirements to introduce secular core curriculum subjects, and preservation of the religious status quo.
Lieberman, meanwhile, has repeatedly insisted that any draft legislation must satisfy both Rav Landau and the Supreme Court, a position that has become central to the negotiations.
According to an examination of the competing proposals, Lieberman’s original 2018 draft legislation is considered substantially more accommodating to the chareidi community than the draft bill promoted by MK Boaz Bismuth during the outgoing Knesset.
Nevertheless, significant legal obstacles threaten the proposed agreement.
Chareidi representatives are reportedly reluctant to accept political promises that may prove impossible to implement once a government is established.
The Supreme Court has previously ruled that the government cannot simply suspend military draft enforcement through an executive decision without appropriate legislative authorization.
Attempts to pass legislation freezing arrests have also encountered opposition from the IDF, which maintains that enforcement measures and arrests are necessary tools for implementing Israel’s military service laws.
Any legislation providing broad exemptions or delaying enforcement against chareidi draft candidates could face opposition from government legal advisers and renewed challenges before the Supreme Court.
These concerns have raised questions about whether Eisenkot’s bloc can offer UTJ guarantees sufficiently binding to secure its support before the new government is sworn in.
Despite those difficulties, figures within the prospective coalition reportedly believe that a year without draft-related arrests would represent a substantial achievement for Asher and the chareidi community, particularly given the absence of an immediate alternative for resolving the issue.
The political calculations are further complicated by the expected position of Shas, headed by Aryeh Deri.
According to current assessments, Shas would remain outside a government headed by Eisenkot. If UTJ were the only chareidi party to cooperate with the new coalition, Eisenkot would likely also require Ra’am, the Arab party headed by Mansour Abbas, to abstain during the government’s formation vote.
Such an arrangement would create another obstacle because Lieberman has publicly declared his opposition to establishing a government dependent on Arab parties, despite his determination to replace Netanyahu.
Recent reports have also revealed that senior figures in UTJ have established regular communication channels with representatives of Ra’am and the Joint List.
The parties have reportedly been exchanging updates about their respective negotiations with Eisenkot’s bloc, an indication of the increasingly complicated parliamentary maneuvering surrounding the formation of the next government.
Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu is working to prevent the arrangement from materializing, maintaining contact with Deri and Asher while warning UTJ against entering an agreement with Eisenkot.
Netanyahu has reportedly cautioned that once the new government is established, UTJ could lose its ability to bring it down if its demands are not fulfilled, because Arab parties might provide the coalition with an outside parliamentary safety net.
Meanwhile, Agudas Yisroel MK Meir Porush has introduced two legislative proposals intended to address the status of yeshiva bochurim.
One bill would establish a permanent military service deferment until age 26, while the second would suspend draft-related arrests for one year.
Newly elected UTJ MK Eliakim Stark has joined Porush as a sponsor of the proposals.
The legislation could provide a basis for further negotiations as Eisenkot’s bloc seeks to secure chareidi cooperation, although the question of whether any proposed suspension of enforcement can withstand legal scrutiny remains unresolved.
{Matzav.com}