
DRAFT LAW DEMANDS: Report Claims Agudas Yisroel Seeking Personal Pledges From 48 Left-Wing MKs, but Senior Lawmakers Deny Involvement
A report that senior figures associated with Agudas Yisroel are demanding personal commitments from all 48 members of Israel’s left-wing parliamentary bloc to support legislation protecting yeshiva bochurim from military conscription has sparked controversy, with two prominent Agudas Yisroel lawmakers denying any knowledge of the reported negotiations.
According to a document disclosed Thursday evening by Channel 12 political commentator Amit Segal, representatives associated with several major chassidic communities have been formulating conditions for possible coalition negotiations with the left-wing bloc, which is attempting to establish a government under Yashar party chairman Gadi Eisenkot.
The reported demands go considerably beyond a general coalition commitment to address the draft issue. They include requiring each of the 48 left-wing Knesset members to personally sign an undertaking to support legislation establishing a military service exemption for full-time yeshiva students.
The proposal would also require a special override provision designed to protect the legislation from being invalidated by Israel’s Supreme Court.
According to the report, a consultation took place Tuesday at the home of the son of the Slonimer Rebbe, attended by another admor, rabbonim and individuals identified with the Gerer and Vizhnitzer chassidic communities.
Participants reportedly discussed the conditions that would have to be met before Agudas Yisroel could consider negotiations with the left-wing parties, potentially through a separate channel from Degel HaTorah, its partner in United Torah Judaism.
The central demand concerned the legal status of yeshiva bochurim whose full-time occupation is Torah study. Under the reported proposal, the incoming government would be required to establish a statutory arrangement allowing such students to defer military service, backed by an explicit commitment to enact the necessary legislation.
The insistence on individual signatures from all 48 left-wing lawmakers would be intended to prevent coalition partners from later withdrawing their support or claiming that the agreement was binding only on party leaders.
Another significant element of the reported document involves a narrowly tailored override clause that would allow the draft arrangement to remain in effect even if the Supreme Court ruled against it.
Those involved in preparing the proposal reportedly pointed to legislation enacted during the government of Yitzchak Rabin that protected restrictions on the importation of nonkosher meat from judicial invalidation.
The document also reportedly referred to direct or indirect contacts involving Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara, although the nature of those discussions and whether any agreement had been reached were not established.
The publication immediately prompted a denial from MK Yitzchok Goldknopf, representing Ger, and MK Yaakov Tessler, representing Vizhnitz.
In a joint statement, the two lawmakers rejected suggestions that they or representatives acting on their behalf had participated in the reported meeting.
“In light of reports published this evening, we wish to clarify that we are not aware of any meeting dealing with the draft law, and no representatives on our behalf participated in any such meeting or discussions,” the two said.
Goldknopf and Tessler emphasized that United Torah Judaism continues working together to secure the status of yeshiva students in accordance with the instructions of the Gedolei Yisroel.
Their denial raised questions about whether the reported document represents an authorized negotiating position or preliminary discussions conducted by individuals without a formal mandate from Agudas Yisroel’s elected representatives.
The controversy comes as Eisenkot intensifies efforts to assemble a governing coalition following the elections to Israel’s 26th Knesset.
The left-wing bloc currently controls 48 seats, leaving it well short of the 61 needed for a parliamentary majority. Bringing Shas and United Torah Judaism into the coalition could potentially provide Eisenkot with the numbers required to form a government.
However, the military draft issue remains a major obstacle, particularly given the longstanding opposition among several left-wing parties to legislation providing broad exemptions for yeshiva students.
Recent reports have suggested that some parties involved in the coalition discussions are considering temporary compromises, including a possible suspension of enforcement measures against yeshiva bochurim while a more permanent legislative arrangement is developed.
The reported Agudas Yisroel demands, however, would require a far more substantial commitment, including explicit legislative guarantees and protections against Supreme Court intervention.
No agreed-upon draft law has yet been presented, and there has been no announcement of a binding coalition agreement between Eisenkot’s bloc and the chareidi parties.
{Matzav.com}