
TWO NONNEGOTIABLE DEMANDS: UTJ Insists on Immediate End to Yeshiva Bochurim Arrests and Signed Draft Law Agreement Before Joining Coalition
United Torah Judaism has reportedly established two central conditions for joining a government led by Gadi Eisenkot: legislation halting the arrests of yeshiva bochurim must be enacted before the new government is sworn in, and coalition leaders must sign a binding political commitment to pass an agreed-upon draft law before approving the government’s first state budget.
The demands, reported by Kikar HaShabbat, have emerged during negotiations between senior UTJ representatives and leaders of the political bloc seeking to establish Israel’s next government. The chareidi party is insisting on concrete legislative commitments rather than general promises concerning the future of yeshiva bochurim.
The first condition addresses the immediate legal situation facing yeshiva students who have not reported for military service. UTJ is demanding that the Knesset enact legislation suspending arrests connected to draft violations before any new coalition formally assumes office.
According to the report, party officials and representatives involved in the negotiations are developing a broader legal framework intended to improve the legislation’s prospects of surviving a challenge before Israel’s Supreme Court.
Rather than applying exclusively to yeshiva bochurim, the proposed measure would cover all individuals classified as draft evaders, including both chareidi and non-chareidi Israelis. The broader application is intended to address potential claims of unequal treatment under the law.
The legislation would be introduced as a temporary provision, remaining in effect during a transitional period until the Knesset completes a comprehensive law regulating military service and the status of full-time yeshiva students.
Those involved in preparing the proposal reportedly believe that presenting it as a temporary arrangement, pending legislation that would establish military recruitment targets, could reduce opposition from senior IDF officials and improve its chances of advancing through the legislative process.
The proposed approach is also intended to avoid the legal difficulties that resulted in the disqualification of the so-called Deri Law shortly before the recent elections. UTJ officials are seeking a measure that can withstand judicial scrutiny rather than legislation that could be struck down after its passage.
The second condition concerns a permanent legislative solution to the draft issue.
UTJ representatives reportedly recognize that completing the legislative process for a comprehensive draft law before the formation of a new government would be difficult, both procedurally and legally. They are therefore demanding that an agreed-upon version of the legislation be finalized before the party commits to entering the coalition.
That proposed legislation would first require the approval of the Moetzos Gedolei HaTorah, ensuring that the final provisions are acceptable to the party’s rabbinic leadership.
Once the wording has been approved, the leaders of the prospective coalition would be required to sign an explicit commitment accepting the legislation and pledging to secure its passage through the Knesset.
Under UTJ’s demands, the law would have to pass its second and third readings, completing the legislative process, before the government could approve its first state budget.
By linking the draft legislation to the budget timetable, UTJ is seeking to establish a clear deadline for fulfilling the coalition’s commitments rather than leaving the issue unresolved indefinitely.
The latest demands represent a more specific negotiating position than the one-year suspension of draft enforcement reportedly considered by Eisenkot’s camp last week. Under that earlier proposal, the incoming government would freeze enforcement measures, including arrests, while coalition partners worked toward a permanent draft arrangement. UTJ’s newly reported position would require legislation to stop the arrests before the government takes office.
The party’s demands are emerging amid a series of previously undisclosed political meetings. Channel 12 political correspondent Dafna Liel reported that UTJ chairman MK Yaakov Asher met privately last week with Yashar party chairman Gadi Eisenkot, marking their first negotiating meeting since Eisenkot received the mandate to form a government.
Asher also held a separate meeting with Yisrael Beytenu chairman Avigdor Lieberman to explore whether the parties could reach an understanding on the draft issue and cooperate in a future coalition.
Lieberman, who has long advocated expanded military service for chareidim, has recently indicated a willingness to negotiate with the chareidi parties following the election results. However, he has maintained his opposition to establishing a government dependent on Arab parties.
The negotiations are further complicated by concerns over whether any proposed draft arrangement could survive a challenge before the Supreme Court. Legal assessments reportedly presented to members of Eisenkot’s bloc have raised doubts about the feasibility of passing legislation that would broadly exempt yeshiva students from military service.
Separately, Channel 12 reported that rabbinic advisers associated with UTJ’s Agudas Yisroel faction have advocated requiring written commitments from all 48 lawmakers belonging to Eisenkot’s four-party bloc. That proposal reportedly includes support for legislation protecting yeshiva students from conscription and a mechanism intended to prevent the Supreme Court from overturning the law.
Earlier this week, Asher publicly identified three broader conditions for UTJ’s participation in any government: legislation regulating the status of yeshiva bochurim and kollel yungeleit, protection of funding for chareidi educational institutions without imposing secular curriculum requirements, and preservation of the longstanding religious status quo.
Asher emphasized that UTJ was not automatically committed to either political bloc and that its decision would depend on whether those fundamental demands were satisfied.
Eisenkot’s efforts to secure chareidi participation are taking place against a difficult parliamentary backdrop. His four-party bloc controls 48 of the Knesset’s 120 seats, meaning that even an agreement with UTJ’s seven lawmakers would not independently provide the 61 seats necessary for a majority coalition.
Shas, which also holds seven seats, has not committed to joining Eisenkot’s government, leaving coalition negotiators to consider several possible arrangements.
No final agreement has been announced, and it remains unclear whether Eisenkot, Lieberman, and the other prospective coalition partners would accept UTJ’s demands for advance legislation and a signed commitment to enact a comprehensive draft law before passage of the state budget.
{Matzav.com}