
“DO NOT ALLOW THIS”: Religious Zionist Rabbonim Urge Rav Dov Landau and Rav Moshe Hillel Hirsch to Block Government Dependent on Arab Parties
Senior rabbonim from Israel’s Religious Zionist community have issued an urgent appeal to Rav Dov Landau and Rav Moshe Hillel Hirsch, calling on the chareidi Torah leadership to prevent the establishment of a government dependent on the support of Arab political parties, warning that such an arrangement raises serious halachic concerns and could have far-reaching consequences.
The letter, sent Wednesday amid ongoing negotiations to form Israel’s next government, was addressed to leading members of the Moetzes Gedolei HaTorah, particularly Rav Landau and Rav Hirsch, as political parties continue exploring possible coalition arrangements following the recent elections.
Among the signatories are prominent rabbonim associated with the leadership of the Toras Haaretz Hatovah rabbinical organization, including Rav Yaakov Ariel, Rav Dovid Chai HaKohen, Rav Isser Klonsky and Rav Eitan Eisman.
The rabbonim expressed concern over the possibility of a government that would lack an independent Jewish parliamentary majority and would instead rely on the participation or support of Arab parties to secure the votes necessary to govern.
In their letter, they argued that such an arrangement would raise fundamental questions under halachah, particularly regarding the appointment of non-Jews to positions of governmental authority.
“We turn to you, also representing the community that follows our guidance, which thirsts for the word of Hashem, meaning halachah. The question now before us is the establishment of a government in Israel that will not rest upon a Jewish majority, but rather upon the inclusion of non-Jews. This means that non-Jews will be appointed as ministers in the government, exercising authority over the holy Jewish people in the Holy Land,” the rabbonim wrote.
The letter cited the Rambam’s rulings concerning the appointment of non-Jews to positions of authority, maintaining that the halachic concern extends beyond formal ministerial appointments.
According to the signatories, a government whose survival depends on the votes of non-Jewish political representatives would effectively grant those representatives substantial authority over the country’s leadership and policies.
“Even the very act of relying on non-Jews means that the non-Jews will determine which government rules over the Jewish people, with all of its decisions dependent upon their agreement and acceptable to them. This, too, is effectively an exercise of authority,” they wrote.
The rabbonim also expressed opposition to the political positions of the Arab parties, accusing elements within those factions of identifying with Israel’s enemies. They cited pesukim from the Nevi’im in support of their objections and argued that the issue should be considered a matter of halachic responsibility rather than ordinary coalition politics.
The appeal comes as Gadi Eisenkot continues efforts to assemble a coalition following the October 27 elections, which left Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu’s bloc without a parliamentary majority. The possibility of cooperation between chareidi parties and the anti-Netanyahu bloc has become a central issue in the negotiations.
Recent reports have indicated that representatives of Degel HaTorah have been examining possible arrangements with Eisenkot’s camp, with the legal status of yeshiva bochurim, the preservation of religious arrangements and funding for chareidi educational institutions among the principal issues under discussion.
However, significant disagreements remain. Reports Tuesday indicated that Rav Landau and Rav Hirsch had rejected a proposed arrangement concerning military exemptions for yeshiva students, complicating efforts to secure chareidi participation in a new government.
The Religious Zionist rabbonim concluded their letter with a direct appeal to the chareidi gedolim, emphasizing their shared commitment to Torah and the welfare of Klal Yisroel.
“We are all brothers together in safeguarding the Torah and its mitzvos and in seeking the welfare of our brethren, the House of Israel, may Hashem protect them. We ask you not to lend your hand to this terrible wrongdoing, the consequences of which no one can foresee,” they wrote.