Logo

Jooish

HomeSitesGroupsStatusPodcasts
Sign InSign Up
Lakewood Alerts

Judge Orders Full Recount After South Toms River Mayoral Election Decided by Just One Vote

Nov 20, 2026·2 min read

A New Jersey Superior Court judge has ordered a full hand recount in the South Toms River mayoral election after incumbent Republican Mayor Oscar Cradle secured a razor-thin, one-vote victory over Democratic challenger Gigi Esparza.

The November 3 election ended with Cradle receiving 441 votes and Esparza receiving 440, making it one of the closest municipal elections in New Jersey this year.

On Thursday, November 19, Superior Court Judge Robert Brenner granted Esparza’s request for a recount despite objections from Cradle, whose attorney argued that the narrow margin alone was not sufficient grounds to order one.

The recount will include all ballots cast across South Toms River’s three election districts. Officials are also examining the significance of three write-in votes and 11 rejected ballots, although those votes cannot automatically be added to either candidate’s total.

Attorneys representing both candidates and the Ocean County Board of Elections are working to establish a recount schedule. With Thanksgiving approaching, the process could extend into December, potentially leaving limited time for additional legal challenges before the borough’s January 1 reorganization.

Esparza will be required to pay $75 for the recount, representing the state’s statutory fee of $25 per election district.

The Ocean County Board of Elections officially certified Cradle’s one-vote victory on Wednesday, November 18. However, the final outcome remains subject to the court-ordered recount, which could determine who serves as South Toms River’s mayor for the next four years.

View original on Lakewood Alerts
HomeSitesGroupsStatusPodcastsSign In