
A Response: Eleven Meshulachim: Eleven Interruptions or Eleven Opportunities?
In response to: Letter: Meshulachim in Shul
What is the Torah outlook on meshulachim collecting in throngs and “disturbing” during Shacharis?
A. Allow yourself first to see the issue from the meshulach’s perspective.
Your wife and children are in Eretz Yisroel. Beneath the facade, their lives are painful: pressure from collectors, foreclosures, children in school, and problems at home that did not disappear when you got on the plane. Your family is waiting for you to come through.
You are alone in a foreign town, sleeping in a second-class, dorm-like environment and eating second-class food or whatever is put out. You have limited spending cash, no car of your own, no familiarity with the country, and you do not speak the language. You have to depend on people for the limited success of the trip: for rides, food, and a place to sleep. You already feel like a second-class citizen before anybody looks at you like a schnorrer.
During the day, you walk or find rides to go knocking on doors in the cold and rain. Disappointment, rejection, missing the homeowner, and the discomfort of being seen are realities. It wears you out. The group rides to Shacharis are your only access to central locations where the men in town gather. You get a dollar here, a dollar there, and many cold rejections. To raise anything substantial, you have to swallow your pride and ask again and again. You know about the mistrust and accusations against you. Yet you have no choice. One gadol described it as their personal suffering of the Holocaust. When was the last time you went through this pressurized, humiliating experience?
Now answer honestly: If it were your wife and children waiting on the other side of the world, with collectors to satisfy and the possible fallout of being unable to marry off your children, foreclosures, divorces, and so on, and this were your only option left, what would you do?
How would you want others to judge you? How would you want others to deal with you? Pause, because we both know the answer! אל תדין את חברך עד שתגיע למקומו (Avos 2:4).
Now reverse the test. Stay in your own seat. Same shul, same pasuk, same five seconds, same meshulach. Change one thing: He is collecting for your beloved child in Eretz Yisroel, and this is the only option you know of. Would you still insist that the gabbai send him out? Or would you hope that the people in the next row look up and give him something, and give it respectfully? Suddenly, it is not a disturbance. Suddenly, there are good reasons. Can we honestly say that kavanah is our issue?
B. Rav Nashri, the author of Meor Eyney Yisroel, related the following firsthand account involving Rav Chaim Kanievsky. A father asked what was a sure sign of a good bochur for a shidduch, since everyone is a “mitzuyan.” Rav Chaim said that if Shacharis is at seven, “Lechatchilah, you should look for a bochur who arrives for Shacharis at 6:45, a full fifteen minutes early.” Six-fifty was bedieved. Six-fifty-five was barely tolerable. At seven sharp: “Don’t take him at all!”
At seven sharp, he has not missed one word. That is precisely the point. Rav Chaim was not checking whether the bochur arrived before the first word. He was checking whether davening mattered enough to him to give it fifteen minutes of his own time before it started. By that standard, seven sharp already shows a lack of care for tefillah!
When Rav Mishkovsky asked Rav Chaim how late one could come to Shacharis, Rav Chaim responded that if it starts at seven, one can come late until seven.
Circling back to the meshulachim: Is kavanah our real reason for being upset? Or is kavanah just the good reason instead of the real one?
What personal interests give us enough reason to come late? What are we willing to take a break for in the middle of our davening? Breaking news? More sleep? Errands? Taavos? Plans? Food? Social interactions?
The people who genuinely value tefillah are often the ones who have room for the meshulach, just as Rav Meir Stern said regarding masmidim: The masmidim are the ones who find time to help at home and do not have the bittul Torah issues.
If we had even a quarter of the pressure this man has, would we not be willing to give up. On coming on time ? On looking at our phones ? Isn’t it embarrassing to pretend that the five seconds loss of kavanah is why I resent a poor man disturbing pope pious? I
Rav Avraham Eliyahu Kaplan recounted his first greeting from the Alter of Slabodka. Young Avraham Elya was saying Aleinu with considerable kavanah. The Alter waited until he finished and bellowed, “Did you have kavanah for even one word?” That was his first shalom aleichem in Slabodka.
There is a more basic question to answer: Did I even hear what I was saying? Can I tell you what I just said in any complete sentence of Pesukei Dezimra?
Rav Wolbe cites Rav Yisroel Salanter regarding the special fondness the yetzer hara has for frumkeit. In Alei Shur (II, p. 152), he writes that a man can build his avodah on frumkeit alone and take on chumros, while it is all egoism cloaked in avodas Hashem. It generates a desire to feel close to Hashem. The minute somebody interrupts that feeling, I look at him with disdain. Others who are not as pious are viewed with annoyance. He writes that the yetzer of frumkeit pushes a person to seek more kavanah and more of the feeling of closeness to Hashem.
Both Rav Chatzkel Levenstein and Rav Elya Lopian write that genuine kavanah is an act of hearing, not thinking more. Having kavanah does not turn annoyance into a sign of yiras Shamayim. On the contrary, it turns it into a sign of something else! The Chofetz Chaim writes that chesed does not detract from dveikus; it is precisely how to get there (Ahavas Chesed, concluding hagahah to the pesichah). Avraham Avinu taught us to ask Hashem to wait so that we can assist guests.
Imagine that Hashem Himself is speaking to you, an experience of connection we cannot even fathom. Three strangers are out in the heat and may need a meal. Rashi says Avraham thought they were Arab travelers. Would you tell Hashem, “Please wait while I take care of them”? Or would you say, “I’m having kavanah. Don’t disturb me. Who told them to come now? Why can’t they come during the shiur?”
Avraham told Hashem to wait. Chazal derive from it: גדולה הכנסת אורחין מהקבלת פני שכינה (Shabbos 127a; Rashi, Bereishis 18:4). Nobody is suggesting that you interrupt Shemoneh Esrei. We are not even talking about needing to speak or skip anything. But the nerve! Guests from Eretz Yisroel keep coming in droves, distracting me from my pious conversation with Hashem.
C. But you may say, “I came to shul with tzaros and want Hashem to answer me.” Look at the order in Yeshayahu: הלא פרוס לרעב לחמך. Then: אז תקרא וה׳ יענה, תשוע ויאמר הנני (58:7-9). Perhaps the man in front of you is the very opportunity Hashem is giving you in the matter you came to daven about. You are looking down at your siddur for an answer and getting annoyed at how Hashem is attempting to provide His answer.
On Rabbi Akiva’s daughter’s wedding day, a poor man came to the door. The Gemara says everybody was busy with the seudah, and nobody heard him. The kallah was busy too. She got up and gave him the portion she herself had been served. She stuck her gold hairpin into the wall; the next morning, she pulled out a snake impaled through its eye. The astrologers had predicted that she would die from a snakebite on her wedding day. Rabbi Akiva said: וצדקה תציל ממות (Shabbos 156b). The same daf tells of a man who spared a fellow worker embarrassment when he had no bread to put into their common meal. He too was saved from a snake.
The Gemara is telling you how Hashem provides the very yeshuah you need. Not convinced? Listen to the following: The Zohar gives you the inside scoop on how Hashem provides those desperate yeshuos. Before a din comes, Hashem sends a person He loves a gift. What gift? ומאן איהו? מסכנא, בגין דיזכי ביה. A poor man, so that he can gain a zechus through him (Zohar, Vayera I 104a).
Hashem does not come with a loudspeaker or a label that says, “This may save your life.” Nor does He tap you on the shoulder. He sends the messages looking precisely like a nuisance, at the exact time you do not want to be bothered.
What do we do instead? Wave Hashem on, congratulate ourselves for our kavanah, and lose the yeshuah as well.
D. What are you getting for that dollar?
This is a mind-boggling investment opportunity, among the best you will get on planet Earth. The expense is tiny. Look at what can be in one small donation:
1. Derech eretz, plus a kiyum of a basic chiyuv. When a poor person asks and you cannot give, the Rema says not to send him away empty-handed. Even a token amount is enough. If you have nothing to give, either speak gently or show apologetically that you wish you could assist more (Shulchan Aruch, Yoreh De’ah 249). If you let him go away as though nobody saw him, the Rambam says, woe to what the price tag for that will be to you (Matnos Aniyim 10:5).
2. Mitzvas tzedakah. You do not have to fund eleven campaigns. The Rema, ibid., and the Rambam specifically say to give a מתנה מועטת to a collector (7:7).
3. Mitzvas gemilus chasadim, besides mitzvas tzedakah. Where you can do so without a hefsek, look up, smile, stand for him when giving, answer his bracha with v’chein l’mar, or tell him you are sorry you cannot give more. You may be the first person that morning who made him feel like a person. That is a mitzvah of סבר פנים יפות as well. Chazal count six brachos for giving a perutah and eleven for being mefayso b’devarim. They say: אין צדקה משתלמת אלא לפי חסד שבה (Avos 1:15; Bava Basra 9b; Sukkah 49b).
4. Hashem’s bracha. It is an open pasuk in Re’eh: כי בגלל הדבר הזה יברכך ה׳ אלהיך בכל מעשך ובכל משלח ידך (Devarim 15:10). Imagine getting a personal Birkas Kohanim every time you do it correctly!
5. His bracha. At minimum, there is אל תהי ברכת הדיוט קלה בעיניך. Who says you know the value of this man’s bracha (Megillah 15a)? But it is more: כי יעמוד לימין אביון. Hashem is with him. The pasuk in Re’eh says his bracha has value.
6. A chance to avert a din. The Zohar’s point is that the chance can be sent to you before you know you need it, or when you already need it. This man could be that chance. “When a person is liable to die, the Holy One, blessed be He, arranges for a poor person to come to him, and he gives him charity; charity saves from death” (Shaarey Rachamim, p. 13, from the GRA).
“If a poor man unexpectedly comes to you when your own means are limited, know that Hashem wants to save you from some misfortune” (Shevet Mussar, chapter 20, §9).
In the Zohar, Vayakheil, vol. 2, 198, it states: “For that poor person is a gift from the Holy One, blessed be He, which He has sent to him. Whoever receives that gift with a welcoming face, fortunate is his portion!”
7. Kaparah. בחסד ואמת יכופר עון. Rabbeinu Yonah brings that pasuk in explaining what chesed can do for a baal teshuvah. Although it is not a substitute for teshuvah, it has tremendous power within it (Mishlei 16:6; Shaarei Teshuvah 1:47).
8. A share in the mitzvah you are supporting. As Rav Avigdor Miller would point out, the first perek of Makkos teaches לנטפל לעושי מצוה כעושי מצוה. You are taking part in a good thing somebody else is doing: supporting a family, a kollel, a yeshivah, or a chesed organization (Makkos 5b).
9. Each gift makes you more of a giver. On והכל לפי רוב המעשה, the Rambam distinguishes between giving a thousand coins in one act and giving one coin a thousand times. The repeated act forms the middah. There is something the eleventh small gift does in you because it is the eleventh act of giving (Rambam on Avos 3:15).
10. You may literally be saving your own rear end. Turnus Rufus asked Rabbi Akiva: If Hashem loves the poor, why does He not feed them Himself? Rabbi Akiva said it is only כדי שניצול אנו בהן מדינה של גיהנם (Bava Basra 10a). And Chazal say explicitly that the poor man does more for the giver than the giver does for the poor man (Rus Rabbah 5:9). Imagine complaining about an opportunity to mitigate your pain in Gehenom!
11. If he is your relative, do not overlook that claim. ומבשרך לא תתעלם. Family has its own priority in tzedakah (Yeshayahu 58:7; Shulchan Aruch, Yoreh De’ah 251:3).
12. Hashem stands on his side. קרוב ה׳ לנשברי לב, כי יעמד לימין אביון (Tehillim 34:19; 109:31). Rav Yisroel Salanter would tremble at the thought of hurting such a man (Kochvay Ohr).
13. You avoid the consequences of the damage his pain will cause you. Normally, if a person calls to Hashem about being wronged, the person calling out is the one who gets hurt as a result. Tzedakah is the exception: וקרא עליך אל ה׳ והיה בך חטא. Here, the cheit will be in you, not in him (Haflaah, ibid.). Rashi adds that it is already a cheit even if the man does not cry out. If he cries out, ממהר אני ליפרע (Rashi, Devarim 15:9). We want Hashem to hear our cry. Do not forget that He hears his.
Today, the Vaad does the homework for you to verify legitimacy. And if you are still worried, “How do I know I’m giving to the right people?” the Chofetz Chaim makes the opposite point. Develop a habit of tov and chesed, and Hashem will send you עניים מהוגנין שיזכה בהן. The person you were tempted to avoid can be the way Hashem gives you a zechus you could never have arranged for yourself (Ahavas Chesed III, ch. 2, hagahah).
“Why doesn’t he go to work?” The Chofetz Chaim used to defend aniyim against exactly that accusation. He pointed out to his son, Rav Leib, that Chazal say that before a person is born, it is decreed whether he will be rich or poor (Niddah 16b). The chiddush is that the gezeirah is not only about how much money he will end up with. It can also determine how much drive he has to go after it. One man is given the energy and ambition that will not let him rest: “אוהב כסף לא ישבע כסף” (Koheles 5:9).
For the poor man, said the Chofetz Chaim, it is as if Hashem filled him with lead. He would rather be poor than undergo the strain of work. We look at the difference and congratulate one man on his ambition while condemning the other for not having it. The Chofetz Chaim’s conclusion is the opposite: “ועלינו לחמול עליו ולהשתתף בצערו” (Chofetz Chaim al HaTorah, Beshalach, note 2, cited in Be’er HaParshah).
The Alshich puts the accusation into our own words: “הלא אביון זה בריא ושלם בגופי … ולמה לא יעשה מלאכה.” He is healthy. He is stronger than I am. Why does he not get a job? The yetzer hara does not stop at getting me not to give. It gets me to make a case against the man himself (Alshich, Re’eh 15:9).
And if you say, “But a man can use that Chofetz Chaim as an excuse not to work,” you are confusing his cheshbon with Hashem and yours. The Chofetz Chaim was not giving the ani an excuse. He was taking one away from you. What the ani does with his own responsibilities is his business between him and Hashem. How you look at him and how you treat him when he comes to you is your responsibility, and that responsibility is what they were addressing.
E. Sedom had the best real estate. Their fear, as the Gemara describes it, was that travelers would come and cost them money: למה לנו עוברי דרכים שאין באים אלינו אלא לחסרינו. They made rules to protect what they had. That was itself part of the indictment: ויד עני ואביון לא החזיקה (Sanhedrin 109a; Yechezkel 16:49).
The Vilna Gaon told the manhigim in Vilna not to call him to an asifah unless they had a new takanah. One day, they called him to discuss keeping poor people from other towns out of Vilna so they would not overburden the city and thereby cause a loss to the poor people residing in Vilna. He became upset and said, “I told you to call me only for a new takanah.” They explained that it was new. “No,” he said, “it’s an old takanah from the Four Lands.” They said that the Vaad Arba Aratzos, the council in Europe that convened to institute takanos, had never instituted this takanah. He said that Sedom, Amorah, Admah, and Tzevoyim had (Chumash HaGra, Parshas Lech Lecha).
The Mishnah Berurah only objects to collections during Krias HaTorah when people will then miss something like the leining or Barchu (92:36).
Usually, if we love assisting others, this becomes a nonissue.
F. The Mishnah Berurah’s objection to collecting during davening is to collecting during Krias HaTorah, and even that is classified as “שלא כהוגן.” He says it is not proper because it causes people to miss the reading and the response of “ברכו את ה׳” (Orach Chaim 92:36). If a meshulach is collecting at another time, quietly, he is not making the congregation miss the words.
If someone is doing שלא כהוגן, that raises a separate question: How do we respond? The Rambam teaches us to rebuke privately and gently, without shaming him (Hilchos De’os 6:7-8). The Chofetz Chaim crystallizes the guidance from the Marganita Tava at the end of Ahavas Chesed: “ואף בשעת תוכחה יוכיח בדברים רכים ובנחת כאילו מוכיח את רבו.” Be as soft and respectful, and give as much thought to your words, as you would if you were speaking to your Rav or Rebbi muvhak!
Collecting during a shiur is even worse than during the Krias HaTorah case. A person entering while a shiur is being given distracts the group from a central speaker. Not only does it cause people to miss his words, but there is bittul Torah derabim. It is surely exactly the kind of loss the Mishnah Berurah identifies, in addition to bittul Torah derabim.
Quiet collecting during Pesukei Dezimra does not cause a collective loss, let alone bittul Torah. It does not cause people to miss words.
How many of us could repeat even one complete sentence of what we just said in a meaningful way? And how much effort are we investing to correct that?
TLS welcomes your letters by submitting them to us via Whatsapp or via email [email protected]
