
BACK BEFORE THE FULL BENCH: All Eleven High Court Justices Reopen Ruling That Let Levin Pick Overseer For Criminal Probe
All eleven justices of Israel’s High Court of Justice convened on Sunday morning for a rare expanded rehearing of the ruling that allowed Justice Minister Yariv Levin to appoint an outside official to oversee the criminal investigation of former Military Advocate General Yifat Tomer-Yerushalmi.
Supreme Court President Yitzchak Amit opened the hearing by stating that the court would not deal with the oversight of the former Military Advocate General’s investigation itself, but only with the principle involved. Amit also disclosed that the daughter of attorney Tzion Amir, who is representing Minister Levin before the court, had been accepted to work for him as a law clerk.
The original ruling, handed down about a year ago, stressed that because the case involved a criminal investigation, and because court rulings bar elected officials from interfering in or influencing criminal probes, the minister’s power was an exceptional option justified by the special circumstances of the Military Advocate General affair. The petitioners and Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara argued that the power must be canceled because it gives elected officials a way to influence criminal investigations.
Justice Yael Willner pressed the petitioners’ attorney from the Movement for Quality Government, Yuval Yoaz, on his position. “If the Attorney General may herself be investigated or give testimony, she will decide who oversees the investigation?” she asked, and later added, “And all of this is preferable to the law that says explicitly that the minister appoints?” Justice Alex Stein told him that the lawmakers “legislated and chose words, so they have meaning,” adding, “In my view, our role is not to decide how to solve a problem, but to interpret how the legislator instructed it to be solved.”
Deputy Supreme Court President Noam Sohlberg also challenged the petitioners’ claim that the clause applies only in an extreme scenario that is hard to imagine. “Where is this found in the words of the legislator? In the explanatory notes to the law? In the debates of the Knesset committee that discussed the law?” he asked. Attorney Ran Rosenberg, representing the State Attorney’s Office and the Attorney General, told the justices that the state was not asking to strike down the law but to narrow its interpretation, so that a conflict of interest would be examined for each individual official rather than for an entire institution, leaving the minister’s power for rare cases with no other option.
Justice Yechiel Kasher and Justice Ofer Grosskopf disagreed with that approach. “There is no dispute that a conflict of interest of the head of a body creates a sweeping disqualification of the entire body,” Grosskopf said. Because the investigation of the former Military Advocate General has already been completed, the ruling is not expected to affect that case. The petitions were filed after Amit froze Minister Levin’s appointment of retired judge Yosef Ben Hamo as overseer of the probe, and the justices made clear that the appointee must be a senior civil servant. When Amit granted the Attorney General’s request for a further hearing last December, he wrote that the outcome “will not apply to the specific investigative process” discussed in the original ruling.
(YWN World Headquarters – NYC)