
INCREDIBLE RECOVERY: Manhattan Shomrim And Chaverim Rescue Two Pairs Of Tefillin From Garbage Compactor After 24-Hour Search
What began as a distressing moment for a father caring for his hospitalized son turned into an extraordinary 24-hour rescue mission, as Manhattan Shomrim, together with Manhattan Chaverim, went to remarkable lengths to recover two precious pairs of tefillin that had been mistakenly discarded in a hospital garbage compactor.
The incredible story, shared with YWN by a Manhattan Shomrim coordinator who personally led the recovery efforts, also includes a remarkable encounter with the Skulener Rebbe of Monsey and an extraordinary incident aboard a flight to New York several weeks earlier.
The incident unfolded Wednesday outside a Manhattan hospital, where a father had been accompanying his son for medical treatments. As they prepared to leave, the father briefly placed his own tefillin and his son’s tefillin on a bench outside the hospital while speaking on the phone.
Within moments, the tefillin disappeared.
Unbeknownst to the father, a cleaning worker had apparently picked up the bags and discarded them with the garbage.
After realizing what had happened, the distraught father contacted Manhattan Shomrim for assistance, setting into motion an intensive investigation that would ultimately involve Manhattan Chaverim, hospital personnel, facility management, and a specially arranged cleanup crew.
The Manhattan Shomrim coordinator described how volunteers spent hours reviewing surveillance footage and tracing the cleaning worker’s movements until they discovered that both pairs of tefillin had been thrown into the hospital’s garbage disposal system, ultimately ending up in a large garbage compactor.
“We spent a tremendous amount of time just trying to figure out where the tefillin had gone,” the coordinator explained. “Once we figured out that they were in the compactor, we immediately started working to stop any more garbage from going into it.”
As garbage continued to accumulate, alternative trucks were brought in to handle the hospital’s waste, allowing the container holding the tefillin to remain untouched while volunteers desperately searched for a way to retrieve them.
But locating the tefillin was only the beginning.
Getting permission to enter a commercial garbage compactor presented enormous logistical, legal, and safety challenges. The company responsible for the equipment initially declined to allow the volunteers access, instead offering financial compensation to replace the tefillin.
“They told us they would pay for everything, even though it was a crazy amount of money,” the coordinator recalled. “But I tried explaining to them that this isn’t something you can just replace with money. These are tefillin. They have Hashem’s name in them. I wasn’t going to give up so easily.”
The coordinator, who said he has never missed a day of putting on tefillin in his life, was determined to do whatever possible to recover the precious mitzvah items.
“I told them I would go across the world to get these tefillin back,” he said. “We weren’t going to just walk away.”
What followed was nearly 24 hours of relentless phone calls, negotiations, and coordination as Manhattan Shomrim explored every possible avenue to obtain authorized access to the compactor.
Eventually, arrangements were made for a licensed cleaning company, special insurance coverage was secured specifically for the operation, and workers equipped with full personal protective equipment were organized.
“We got insurance just for this job,” the coordinator explained. “We arranged for a licensed company, got the proper protective equipment, and worked through every possible obstacle until we finally had a way to get inside.”
Manhattan Chaverim was brought in to assist with the physical recovery operation, providing members and specialized protective equipment needed to search through the garbage.
With the necessary arrangements finally in place, the hospital’s management and facilities team helped coordinate the operation. The volunteers and cleanup crews entered the massive garbage container and began the painstaking process of searching through its contents.
And then came the incredible moment everyone had been hoping and davening for.
Both pairs of tefillin were found intact.
After nearly a full day of uncertainty, enormous effort, and seemingly insurmountable obstacles, the father’s tefillin and his son’s tefillin had been recovered.
But as remarkable as the rescue itself was, what the coordinator learned later that night added an entirely new dimension to the story.
“When I went to meet the father and his son later that night, he asked me how we managed to do it,” the coordinator related. “He had heard that getting something back from a garbage compactor was almost impossible.”
During their conversation, the father revealed that while the volunteers had been working tirelessly to recover the tefillin, he had been seeking brachos and davening for their safe return.
The father had traveled to the Skulener Rebbe of Monsey, where he explained the situation and asked for a bracha that his tefillin and his son’s tefillin would be recovered.
According to the father, the Rebbe gave him a warm bracha, assuring him that the tefillin would be found, and even danced with him.
What happened next was extraordinary.
“The father told me that the exact time he was dancing with the Skulener Rebbe was when we found the tefillin,” the coordinator recounted. “One of our members called him as he was leaving the Rebbe and told him we had found them.”
The remarkable timing left those involved deeply moved, but the father had another extraordinary story to share.
Several weeks earlier, while flying to New York for his son’s medical treatments, the father had an unusual encounter with a flight attendant.
Throughout the flight, the flight attendant repeatedly approached him, asking whether he had already put on tefillin that day.
The father assured him that he had, but the flight attendant continued asking.
“Eventually, the father asked the flight attendant if he wanted to put on tefillin himself,” the coordinator said. “The flight attendant said yes, and the father helped him put on tefillin.”
But the encounter didn’t end there.
After putting on tefillin, the flight attendant told the father that he had a friend aboard the aircraft who had never put on tefillin in his entire life.
The father gladly agreed to help him as well.
And right there, thousands of feet above the ground, the second man put on tefillin for the very first time in his life, celebrating what was effectively his Bar Mitzvah.
It was only during his conversation with the Shomrim coordinator that the father revealed the remarkable connection between that incident and Wednesday’s rescue.
The very same pair of tefillin that had been used to help a Yid put on tefillin for the first time aboard that flight was among the pairs recovered from the garbage compactor.
“He only told me that story because I was explaining to him how much tefillin means to me personally,” the coordinator said. “I told him I’ve never missed a day of putting on tefillin in my life, and I wasn’t going to give up on getting his tefillin back. Then he told me what happened on the plane. It’s a wild story.”
The coordinator emphasized that while locating missing belongings is something Shomrim regularly assists with, recovering items that have already entered a garbage compactor is an entirely different challenge.
“Sometimes in this business, we have to accept that something is gone, especially when it ends up in the garbage and nobody knows where it went,” he explained. “But in this case, the father called us right away, and that gave us the opportunity to start working immediately. We were determined to do everything possible.”
Those involved emphasized that the remarkable recovery would not have been possible without the dedication and cooperation of numerous individuals who went far beyond their regular responsibilities.
Special appreciation was extended to Khemraj Tiwari, Account Manager at CBRE, and the CBRE executive team, for their tireless efforts in helping coordinate the complicated recovery operation and overcoming the many logistical hurdles.
A special thank-you was also extended to Askan Israel Rosman, who serves as a liaison to the hospital and played a major role in bringing the various parties together and ensuring that the operation could proceed.
The extraordinary determination of Manhattan Shomrim, the assistance of Manhattan Chaverim, and the cooperation of hospital and facilities personnel turned what initially appeared to be an impossible situation into an unforgettable recovery.

(YWN World Headquarters – NYC)