
CHUTZPAH: NYS Education Commissioner Betty Rosa Still Trying To Punish Yeshiva Students
Here she goes again! New York State Education Commissioner Betty Rosa is back to her old ways of discriminating against yeshiva education and yeshiva graduates.
The State Education Department has proposed regulations that would preclude many yeshiva graduates from participating in New York’s Tuition Assistance Program (TAP) and other state financial aid programs.
To make matters worse, in targeting yeshivas and yeshiva graduates, SED is ignoring directives from the New York Legislature and the State’s highest court, the New York Court of Appeals.
In June 2025, the Court of Appeals held that SED did not have the authority to direct nonpublic schools to close or to direct parents to switch their children out of a nonpublic school that SED says is not substantially equivalent. That school remains a school. And in May 2025, the Legislature amended the Education Law to expressly permit nonpublic schools to administer a phased-in series of assessment tests.
Now, SED is ignoring both of those developments, and proposed regulations that declares graduates of schools that do not have an SED equivalency determination or that established equivalency by utilizing one of the pathways created by the Legislature to be ineligible for TAP and other financial aid.
PEARLS and Torah Umesorah jointly submitted a comprehensive memorandum in opposition to this blatantly illegal and discriminatory move by SED. The PEARLS and Torah Umesorah memo presents a detailed statutory analysis, relevant court precedents and compelling legal arguments demonstrating that the proposed regulations exceed the Department’s authority, contradict the Legislature’s express directives, and would improperly deprive students of financial aid even when their schools selected a legally recognized substantial equivalence pathway.
PEARLS and TU called upon SED to withdraw these proposed regulations. They reminded SED that after the Court of Appeals and the Legislature’s actions, a lower court applied them to smack down SED’s attempt to withhold busing, special education services and other benefits from students attending yeshivas that were deemed not to be substantially equivalent. That court held that under the Court of Appeals decision, nonpublic schools deemed not to provide substantially equivalent instruction remain “schools” for purposes of the Education Law and that the phase-in “deems any school that elects to use the two new assessment pathways to be providing a substantially equivalent education and is applicable to ‘all nonpublic schools.’” PEARLS and Torah Umesorah warned SED that if the proposed regulation are adopted, it will share the same fate as its earlier attempt to declare yeshiva students ineligible for state benefits.
A copy of the PEARLS and Torah Umesorah memorandum can be read here.