
DIPLOMATIC BACKLASH: U.S. And Israel Abstain On Iran Human Rights Resolution, Citing Problematic Language
Israel and the United States abstained Wednesday on a United Nations resolution condemning Iran’s human rights abuses, saying portions of the text diverted attention from holding Tehran accountable. The decision drew criticism from Iranian opposition activists and a former Israeli diplomat.
The resolution, titled “Situation of human rights in the Islamic Republic of Iran,” passed the UN General Assembly’s Third Committee with 76 countries voting in favor, 27 opposed and 64 abstaining.
Introduced by Canada and several European countries, the measure condemns violent repression, executions, arbitrary detention, torture and discrimination against women and minorities. It calls on Iran to release people arbitrarily imprisoned, stop executing protesters and permit independent investigations.
The text specifically addresses demonstrations that began on December 28, 2025, condemning the mass killing of protesters in January, the detention of tens of thousands and nationwide internet shutdowns.
It also discusses civilian casualties and infrastructure damage resulting from the conflict in Iran and the wider region. Among the incidents highlighted is a strike on an elementary school in Minab that the resolution says killed at least 156 people, including approximately 120 schoolchildren.
Explaining Washington’s abstention, the American delegation thanked Canada for leading the initiative but argued that the resolution was insufficiently forceful toward the Iranian authorities.
“Unfortunately, this resolution does not go far enough in holding the regime accountable for this behavior and instead includes language that distracts from that purpose,” the U.S. representative said.
“Let no one mistake our abstention for any softening toward Tehran,” the delegation added. It accused Iranian authorities of decades of repression and of killing tens of thousands of protesters during the December and January demonstrations.
Israel offered a similar explanation, emphasizing that its decision did not diminish its solidarity with Iranians opposing the regime.
“Our abstention should not be seen as a weakening of that commitment,” the Israeli representative said, citing “serious concerns regarding the inclusion of selective language” that distracted from the resolution’s central purpose.
The Israeli delegation also accused Tehran of prioritizing nuclear and ballistic missile programs and funding Hamas, Hezbollah and the Houthis while neglecting its own citizens.
Iran rejected the resolution as politically motivated. Its representative accused other countries of exploiting human rights concerns while subjecting Iran to military attacks, economic pressure and efforts to encourage domestic unrest.
China, Russia, North Korea and Iran were among those voting against the measure. Countries joining Israel and the United States in abstaining included Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, Qatar, Egypt, Brazil and South Africa.
Iranian opposition activist Niyak Ghorbani sharply criticized the American and Israeli decisions, asking why countries regarded as allies of the Iranian people had declined to support the condemnation.
“Our closest friends couldn’t even press ‘yes’?” he wrote, urging both governments to stand unequivocally with Iranians facing arrest, torture and violence.
Former Israeli ambassador Daniel Carmon also criticized the abstentions, while acknowledging that the objections to the wording could be legitimate. He argued that Israel and the United States could support the resolution while formally distancing themselves from particular provisions.
Carmon urged both countries to reconsider before the measure reaches the full General Assembly, saying that approach would allow them to join the condemnation of Tehran without endorsing passages they oppose.
(YWN World Headquarters – NYC)