Mayor Mamdani himself posted the photo to his social media account, showing him attending an Iftar gathering during Ramadan. In the image, he is seen holding a plate of hamantaschen while seated among attendees. The caption on the post reads “Iftar, Day 13.” The image quickly began circulating online, with many observers noting the unusual juxtaposition of a Ramadan fast breaking meal and the traditional Purim pastry.

The pastry represents Haman, the villain in the Book of Esther who plotted to annihilate the Jewish people. Jews eat hamantaschen on Purim to remember that Haman’s plan ultimately failed and that the Jewish people survived his decree.

For many Jewish observers, the optics feel deeply ironic. Mamdani has faced criticism for his response to pro Hamas demonstrations where protesters shouted “Globalize the Intifada,” a phrase many Jews view as a call for violence against Jews worldwide. He has also supported efforts that critics say would shield pro Hamas protesters from criminal consequences tied to protest related actions.

Online, many commenters quickly pointed out the symbolism.

“Is that Mamdani eating his own ears?” wrote David Rosen on social media, referencing the tradition that hamantaschen represent Haman’s ears.

“Only on Purim could you see something this symbolic,” commented Rachel Goldberg. “The pastry that represents the downfall of someone who wanted to destroy the Jews.”

Another commenter, Moshe Klein, wrote, “The irony is unbelievable. The whole point of hamantaschen is celebrating the defeat of someone who wanted the Jews wiped out.”

Others responded with humor. One viral meme circulating online shows a photoshopped image combining Mamdani with Haman from the Purim story, complete with a Persian style crown and triangular hamantaschen ears.

“Purim satire basically writes itself this year,” joked Avi Feldman.

On a holiday that commemorates a failed attempt to destroy the Jewish people, the symbolism of the moment has not gone unnoticed.