
Agudath Israel Urges New Jersey Residents to Oppose Bill Ahead of Assembly Vote
Agudath Israel of America is urging New Jersey residents to immediately contact their state Assembly members and oppose legislation it says poses a serious threat to religious liberty, free speech, and parental rights.
In an alert distributed ahead of a scheduled Thursday vote in the New Jersey General Assembly, Agudah warned that A2218/S2260 contains broad provisions that could expose rabbanim, educators, counselors, schools, and even parents to costly civil lawsuits and potential legal penalties for expressing views or providing guidance regarding gender-related medical procedures.
The organization said that while supporters characterize the measure as a “shield law” intended to protect access to certain healthcare services, the bill’s language extends far beyond that purpose and could have unintended consequences for religious communities.
The legislation would allow individuals of any age to sue those accused of “interfering” with their decision to obtain gender-related healthcare services. The bill would permit claims for damages related to alleged harm to a person’s reputation, financial losses, and emotional distress, including mental anguish and pain and suffering.
Agudah argues that many of the bill’s key terms are vague and undefined, creating uncertainty about what conduct could be considered unlawful. The organization says the legislation could discourage religious leaders, educators, and parents from offering guidance consistent with their beliefs for fear of litigation.
“No one should face the threat of a lawsuit for offering religious counsel, parental guidance, or expressing deeply held convictions,” Agudah wrote in its appeal.
Agudah further contends that the bill raises significant constitutional concerns, arguing that it could infringe upon protections for freedom of religion and free speech while also limiting the ability of parents and community leaders to discuss sensitive issues with children and families.