Several roshei yeshiva and senior rabbonim within the Religious Zionist community sharply criticized a directive issued by Israel’s Education Ministry instructing boarding schools to send their students home for Shabbos following the outbreak of the war with Iran.

Speaking to Arutz Sheva, the rabbonim said the sweeping order was applied to institutions across the country without proper consideration of the circumstances at each yeshiva or campus. According to them, officials failed to examine whether individual schools had adequate protected areas where talmidim could remain safely, and the decision was issued without meaningful consultation with recognized poskim or other gedolei Torah.

Some mechanchim explained that while certain institutions may indeed have lacked sufficient shelter and therefore needed to send their students away, many others were properly equipped with secure areas and could have safely kept their talmidim on campus for Shabbos. They argued that issuing a blanket directive caused unnecessary chillul Shabbos in situations where there was no clear or immediate danger.

One prominent rav described the ministry’s action as “scandalous,” saying that schools suddenly found themselves placed in an impossible situation—forced to choose between obeying government orders or remaining faithful to their hashkafah and halachic standards. In some instances, he said, institutions that hesitated to carry out the directive faced pressure from authorities and were compelled to make their own independent decisions.

According to reports, in several locations buses arrived during Shabbos in order to take the students home. In other cases, parents traveled to pick up their children themselves. However, some yeshivos chose to delay the departures until after Shabbos, deciding it was preferable to wait before arranging transportation.

At least one evacuation, according to the reports, was carried out only after receiving explicit authorization from a local rav.