New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani sparked backlash Tuesday after invoking Ireland’s history of oppression to draw a comparison to what he described as a “genocide” in Gaza, using a St. Patrick’s Day gathering to criticize what he called widespread silence on the Israel-Hamas war.

Mamdani made the remarks while hosting Ireland’s former president, Mary Robinson, at a breakfast at Gracie Mansion marking the start of the city’s St. Patrick’s Day celebrations.

During his comments, Mamdani reflected on Ireland’s past struggles and framed them as a lens through which to view current global conflicts, praising the Irish tradition of standing in solidarity with oppressed groups. He did not reference conditions inside Iran under its ruling regime.

“Who can better understand those who weep than those who have been made to weep for so long? The story of the Irish, both in Ireland and in New York City, is at one time a story of oppression, of subjugation, and of discrimination,” Mamdani said.

He then commended Robinson, Ireland’s first female president, for her longstanding advocacy on human rights and her vocal support for Palestinians.

“I say this as over the past few years, as we’ve witnessed a genocide unfold before our eyes, there has been deafening silence from so many,” he said.

“For those who have long cared about universal human rights and the extension of them to Palestinians, silence, however, is nothing new, for Palestinians are so often left to weep alone. Yet, former President Robinson has never been silent.”

Mamdani also expressed appreciation to Irish New Yorkers for their role in advancing what he described as a shared pursuit of justice.

The mayor’s comments quickly drew criticism from Bill Donohue, president of the Catholic League, who accused Mamdani of turning a cultural celebration into a political platform.

“Mamdani is a master of the politics of victimization. He delighted his left-wing Irish friends by saying, ‘The story of the Irish, both in Ireland and in New York City, is at one time a story of oppression, of subjugation, and of discrimination,’” Donohue said in a statement.

“This is the mentality of the Left. He sees oppression everywhere, nicely teeing it up for guys like him to rescue victims from their oppressors.”

Neil Cosgrove, who serves as political education chairman of the Ancient Order of Hibernians in America, said the holiday should remain focused on Irish-American heritage, even while acknowledging broader global concerns.

“Today is a day to celebrate the Irish-American community. There are 364 other days to go into areas of other politics,” he told The NY Post.

“I think the world needs to hear the message of Saint Patrick — they need to hear it and heed it everyday but certainly we shouldn’t lose that message with other messages on Saint Patrick’s day.”

Robinson, speaking briefly at the event attended by roughly 50 people, highlighted the many ongoing conflicts around the world and suggested that Ireland’s own history shapes how its people view suffering elsewhere.

“We know others are living under the shadow of war and suffering in Iran, in Lebanon, in Palestine, in Ukraine, in Sudan, and Democratic Republic of Congo, and in too many other places,” she said.

“For many Irish people, these realities resonate deeply, as the mayor has said, our own history holds memories of famine, exile, and conflict,” she said.

“Perhaps because of that, many recognize echoes of Ireland’s past within the suffering of others today, in the pain of displacement and the enduring human longing for dignity, justice, and self-determination.”

Mamdani’s remarks came just one day after he met privately with Orthodox Jewish leaders and assured them that combating antisemitism remained a key priority for his administration.

The following morning, before participating in St. Patrick’s Day events, Mamdani again spoke publicly about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. He later attended Mass at St. Patrick’s Cathedral, where he was seen smiling as New York’s newly installed archbishop, Ronald Hicks, walked past at the start of the service.

He then joined the city’s annual parade up Fifth Avenue alongside NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch, though he left early to attend a luncheon with Hicks.

After the Mass, Mamdani was asked to clarify his comparison between Irish history and the Palestinian situation. He said his remarks were rooted in admiration for Ireland’s historical stance against injustice.

“What we’ve seen time and time again is that it has been the Irish who have been standing up whenever there’s been a person or people oppressed, whether it has been being the first Western government to ban South African goods during apartheid, or it has been this very former president (Robinson) that we honored today standing up in support of Palestinian freedom,” he said.

Mamdani added that Irish immigrants to the United States often faced discrimination themselves, referencing signs that once read “Irish Need Not Apply.”

“It is truly a testament to the Irish spirit of perseverance, of struggle and solidarity that we are here in the city today,” he told reporters.

“I always take inspiration from the Irish.”

A day earlier, Mamdani appeared uncertain when asked about his position on Irish unification — the proposal to bring all 32 counties of Ireland under one independent government — despite confirming his participation in the parade.

“I gotta be honest, I haven’t thought enough on that question,” he said.

His response contrasted with that of New York Gov. Kathy Hochul, who offered a clearer position while marching in the parade.

“I believe in unifying the Irish people, of course,” Hochul told The NY Post while marching in the parade.

{Matzav.com}