A new controversy has emerged among hundreds of volunteers from the Gerer chassidus who serve as responders with Magen David Adom after the community’s rabbinic technology committee issued a formal letter questioning the permissibility of certain operational devices.

In the letter sent to MDA leadership, the committee stated that the POC devices—commonly referred to by volunteers as the “yellow device”—no longer meet the chassidus’s accepted standards. The announcement has left many volunteers grappling with both hashkafic and technological concerns.

According to the document, the decision followed a thorough review by experts working with the committee, who concluded that the devices are not fully secure. “We hereby inform you that MDA POC devices (the yellow device) are not approved for use by Gerer chassidic responders due to the existing breach,” the letter stated.

The committee pointed to a specific issue that led to its ruling: the Waze navigation app. According to the rabbonim, it is possible to access an external, unfiltered network through the app, creating what they described as a serious breach in the community’s technological safeguards.

At the same time, the committee emphasized that the decision is not meant to impose an impossible standard, and that it is open to dialogue in order to find a technical solution that would allow volunteers to continue their work. Any device would need to undergo further testing or receive certification from an approved oversight body before being permitted for use, the committee clarified.

Sources familiar with the matter said the letter was not intended to immediately pull devices out of service or halt volunteer activity, but rather to highlight the issue to MDA leadership so that stronger filtering solutions can be implemented in line with the chassidus’s strict requirements.

The issue now rests with MDA officials, who rely on hundreds of chareidi volunteers nationwide. The organization will need to balance maintaining operational readiness and constant communication with dispatch centers against the stringent religious standards set by rabbinic authorities.

Within the chassidus, there is hope that ongoing discussions with MDA will produce a workable solution, one that ensures the life-saving device is free of any technological concerns, allowing volunteers to continue their critical work under rabbinic guidance.

{Matzav.com}